• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact + Collaborate
  • Privacy Policy
  • Nav Connect

    Subscribe Via Email 

    • Bloglovin
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Snapchat
    • Twitter

Whimsical September

A Family + Lifestyle Blog

  • Favorite Things
  • Motherhood
    • Pregnancy
    • Registry
    • Slice of Life
    • Potty Training
    • A Day in the Life
    • All The Feels
    • Activities/Crafts
    • Hadley’s B-days
    • Sadie’s B-Days
  • Military Life
    • PCSing
    • Home Ownership
    • Deployment 2011-2012 (Afghanistan)
    • Deployment 2013 (Afghanistan)
    • Deployment 2015-2016 (Kuwait)
    • West Point Days
    • Friendships
    • Other
  • Travel
    • With Little Ones
    • Beaches/Tropical
    • Disney World
    • Europe
    • More Fun Places
  • Home + DIY
    • Before and After Home Tour
    • Bathrooms
    • DIY Projects
    • Painting Projects
    • Bedrooms
    • Kitchen
    • Playroom
  • Style + Beauty
    • Stitch Fix Reviews
    • Fashion
    • Make Up + Skin Care
  • Recipes
    • Meats
    • Side Items
    • Desserts
    • Comfort Food
    • Pasta
    • Healthy Choices
    • Christmas
  • Blogging
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact + Collaborate
  • Privacy Policy
  • Nav Connect

    Subscribe Via Email 

    • Bloglovin
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Snapchat
    • Twitter

Eat · Parties · Party Planning 14 Comments

Homemade Carrot Cake: The Crowd-Pleasing Two-Layer Cake

This is my favorite homemade carrot cake recipe. I hope this recipe is a hit with your family as well!

Our whole family knows that we’re in for a treat when Jamie’s grandmother is in the kitchen.

I’ve mentioned Mamaw before and what a special person she is in my life, so I was thrilled when she decided to join us for Jamie’s birthday and Christmas this year here in Kansas. Within an hour of arriving at our home, she had her pans out that she’d packed in her suitcase (so adorable) and was ready to bake Jamie a cake for his birthday.

Homemade Carrot Cake

After making this two layer carrot cake one time, you'll never bake a different carrot cake again. This cake is rich, creamy, and perfect for all kinds of occasions and seasons (not just birthdays). The prep is easy with simple ingredients likely already in your house. Enjoy immensely!

She invited Hadley to “help”, so they spent a while in the kitchen that afternoon baking what would turn out to be the best homemade cake I’ve ever tasted. But I wasn’t surprised. Any recipe that is hand-written on a yellowed index card is likely one of those “true blue” recipes – the kind that is quickly scribbled and passed on to every person that inevitably is asking for the recipe.

two layer carrot cake two layer carrot cake

This recipe makes enough for two delicious round cakes ready to be iced with a rich, creamy homemade pecan vanilla frosting.

two layer carrot cake

After making this two layer carrot cake one time, you'll never bake a different carrot cake again. This cake is rich, creamy, and perfect for all kinds of occasions and seasons (not just birthdays). The prep is easy with simple ingredients likely already in your house. Enjoy immensely!

Because this cake is quite rich (in the best way), a little sliver goes a long way. I actually didn’t even end up making a Christmas Day dessert two days later because the whole family still only had eyes and a sweet tooth for some leftover cake.

After making this carrot cake one time, you'll never bake a different carrot cake again. This cake is rich, creamy, and perfect for all kinds of occasions and seasons (not just birthdays). The prep is easy with simple ingredients likely already in your house. Enjoy immensely!
{click here to see more pictures from Jamie’s “cow party”}

If you’d love to impress your family members or friends during a birthday party or another type of social event, add this cake to your “must bake ASAP” list. I hope you love it as much as we do!two layer carrot cake

A few quick notes:

  • Hadley (age three) did not like this cake, as it was a bit too “mature” for her tastebuds! She’s a very picky eater though, so some children would devour it!
  • This cake tastes best prepared 24 hours in advance.
  • Because the icing contains cream cheese, we kept the cake refrigerated after initially serving and then ate it cold the next few days. The cake truly tasted better and better each day, as the flavors continue to mesh so deliciously well together.
After making this two layer carrot cake one time, you'll never bake a different carrot cake again. This cake is rich, creamy, and perfect for all kinds of occasions and seasons (not just birthdays). The prep is easy with simple ingredients likely already in your house. Enjoy immensely!
{hover and pin for future baking!}

Save Print
Crowd-Pleasing Two-Layer Carrot Cake
Prep time:  15 mins
Cook time:  35 mins
Total time:  50 mins
Serves: 16 servings
 
Ingredients
  • Cake:
  • 2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 2 tsp baking soda
  • 2 tsp cinnamon
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 1 scant cup of vegetable oil
  • 4 eggs
  • 3 cups finely grated carrots (we put ours in a food processor for a few seconds)
  • Frosting:
  • 1 8oz. package cream cheese
  • 1 stick softened butter
  • 4 cups powdered sugar
  • 1 cup chopped pecans
  • 2 tsp vanilla
Instructions
  1. Cake:
  2. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  3. Mix together dry ingredients.
  4. Add oil.
  5. Add eggs one at a time, stirring well between each.
  6. Add carrots.
  7. Divide mixture between two greased round cake pans and bake for 35 minutes.
  8. Frosting:
  9. Cream butter and cream cheese together.
  10. Sift powdered sugar into creamed mixture.
  11. Add vanilla and chopped pecans.
  12. If too dry, add 2 tsp milk (You want the icing to be pretty firm, so only add milk if not spreadable.)
  13. Allow cake to cool entirely before icing. Enjoy immensely!
3.5.3226

Psst! Did you know that our not-so-secret family meatloaf recipe was also passed down from Mamaw? It’s the most popular recipe on my blog, and for good reason! It was viewed over 60k times in eight months last year. Crazy! It’s just so good. In fact, I’m making it tonight. 🙂

More great recipes? click here.

Erica
Erica

Hi! I’m Erica, and I absolutely adore sharing my life on this website with you! I come here almost daily to blab about all of the things related to being a regular wife and mother in today’s ever-evolving society. I share about our new home, what’s on our kitchen table, what we’re hanging in our closets, where we’re traveling to next, my crazy 5 a.m. work outs, how I make time for girlfriends, our faith, and much more. We always have a lot of balls in the air and somewhat thrive on the chaos. I believe in the power of story-telling as a form of inspiration and entertainment, so I’m here to do both! I was born and raised in north Alabama and recently re-planted roots here again after my husband transitioned out of the Army (he is now in the Reserve and it’s going so well!) I’m a super proud mom to three little girls (ages 7, 4, and 1) who seem to be the stars of the show around here (for good reason – they’re pretty great!) I’m so glad you found me and are here reading! I hope we can get to know each other here on the blog as well as Facebook and/or Instagram. xoxo

January 8, 2017

Previous Post: « Friday Favorites: Make Up, a New Car Seat, Two Blogging Resources, and More
Next Post: Turning our Sunroom into a Playroom »

Primary Sidebar

Meet Erica

Hi! I’m Erica, and I absolutely adore sharing my life on this website with you!

I come here almost daily to blab about all of the things related to being a regular wife and mother in today’s ever-evolving society. I share about our new home, what’s on our kitchen table, what we’re hanging in our closets, where we’re traveling to next, my crazy 5 a.m. work outs, how I make time for girlfriends, our faith, and much more. We always have a lot of balls in the air and somewhat thrive on the chaos.

I believe in the power of story-telling as a form of inspiration and entertainment, so I’m here to do both! I was born and raised in north Alabama and recently re-planted roots here again after my husband transitioned out of the Army (he is now in the Reserve and it’s going so well!) I’m a super proud mom to three little girls (ages 7, 5, and 1) who seem to be the stars of the show around here (for good reason – they’re pretty great!)

I’m so glad you found me and are here reading! I hope we can get to know each other here on the blog as well as Facebook and/or Instagram. xoxo

Everywhere

Footer

Instagram did not return a 200.

Follow On Instagram

Whimsical September © 2025 · Blog Design by Freeborboleta · Built On The Genesis Framework

[jetpack_subscription_form title=”SUBSCRIBE” subscribe_text=”Keep up with Erica & Whimsical September by receiving new post notifications in your inbox. This is the easiest way to never miss a new post! What they’re eating, what they’re doing, where they’re going… she shares it all!”]